Movies like The New Guy in Town

Loved The New Guy in Town (2026)? Here are 8 films and shows with a similar vibe and story (Horror, Thriller, Mystery), ranked by how close they are. Find your next watch and stream it on MovieNode.

The Friend

4.5

The Unsettling

I Don't Like It Here

4.2

Old Strangers

Those Kids

5.0

There's a New Killer in Town

1.0

The New Girl

6.2

Here on Out